"Past performance" is the evaluation factor that most worries new federal contractors. Solicitations ask for recent, relevant contracts, and you may have none with the government. The good news is that the rules do not shut you out, and there are practical ways to show you can do the work and to build a federal record. This guide is general information, not legal advice.
How evaluators treat a firm with no record
The rule is in FAR 15.305(a)(2) (opens in a new tab). For negotiated procurements, past performance is evaluated on recent and relevant work. If an offeror has no record of relevant past performance, or the information is not available, the offeror "may not be evaluated favorably or unfavorably on past performance." In practice, you get a neutral rating.
A neutral rating is not a win. In a best value tradeoff, a competitor with strong, relevant past performance can still beat you on that factor. But it means a lack of history is not a disqualification, and your technical approach and price can carry the decision. In lowest price technically acceptable evaluations, past performance is often rated simply acceptable or unacceptable, and a neutral rating is generally treated as acceptable.
Simplified acquisitions and sealed bids weigh past performance less, or not at all as a scored factor; responsibility checks still apply. These are often the easiest first wins.
What you can cite instead
The same FAR section says evaluators should take into account past performance of:
- Predecessor companies: if your business grew out of another company.
- Key personnel who have relevant experience: your project manager may have run similar contracts at a previous employer.
- Subcontractors that will perform major or critical aspects of the work.
So even a new company can present relevant experience, if the solicitation allows it. Read the instructions carefully: some limit references to the company itself, some cap the number of references, and some require a past performance questionnaire to be sent to each reference.
Commercial, state and local work
Most solicitations define relevance by scope, size and complexity, not by customer. A cleaning company that services hospitals has relevant experience for a VA clinic contract. A software firm that built a case management system for a county has relevant experience for a federal one. Present it in the same format you would use for federal work:
- Customer and point of contact who will answer
- Contract period and value
- Scope, in the terms the solicitation uses
- Results: on time, on budget, measurable improvements
- Why it is relevant to this requirement
A reference format you can reuse
Keep one record per project, so you can drop the right ones into any proposal:
| Field | Example |
|---|---|
| Customer and contact | Regional hospital system; facilities director, phone and email |
| Period and value | March 2023 to present; about $400,000 a year |
| Contract type | Fixed monthly price with on-call work at agreed rates |
| Scope | Custodial and floor care for 250,000 square feet across three buildings |
| Results | Passed every infection-control audit; no missed shifts in two years |
| Relevance | Same type of facility, similar square footage, same shift pattern as the solicitation |
Ask each contact in advance whether they will answer a reference call or a questionnaire, and tell them which opportunity it is for.
Ways to build a federal record
1. Start small
Simplified acquisitions (up to the simplified acquisition threshold, generally $350,000) and micro-purchases (generally up to $15,000) are faster to compete for and less dependent on past performance. A few small, well-delivered orders give you federal references.
2. Subcontract to a prime
Working under a prime contractor on a federal contract builds directly relevant experience. Ask the prime for a written reference and to describe your role when the government evaluates the prime. See subcontracting with prime contractors.
3. Team on a bid
Under FAR Subpart 9.6 (opens in a new tab), you can form a contractor team arrangement with a firm that has the record you lack, as prime or sub. The team's combined experience is evaluated, subject to the solicitation's rules.
4. Use SBA's Mentor-Protégé program
A protégé and an experienced mentor can form a joint venture to compete for set-asides the protégé qualifies for (SBA (opens in a new tab)). Joint venture work builds experience you can cite, and the mentor's capabilities strengthen the bid.
5. Answer sources sought notices
A strong sources sought response introduces you to the contracting office before evaluation, and can help get work set aside for small businesses, where competition is narrower.
6. Target set-asides you qualify for
On small business, 8(a), HUBZone, WOSB or SDVOSB set-asides, you compete against firms of similar size, who often have thin federal records too. See set-asides explained.
Once you have federal work: protect your record
Agencies record contractor performance in the Contractor Performance Assessment Reporting System (CPARS (opens in a new tab)), under FAR Subpart 42.15 (opens in a new tab). Future contracting officers read those evaluations.
- Deliver on the first contract as if your next five depend on it. They do.
- Keep records: deliverables, dates, metrics, customer emails praising the work.
- Read your CPARS evaluation when it is issued. You can comment on it and provide information within the response period if you disagree.
- Ask for a final meeting with the contracting officer's representative to discuss performance before the evaluation is written.
Presenting thin experience well
- Be specific. One detailed, relevant reference beats five vague ones.
- Explain relevance in the solicitation's terms. Map each reference to the requirement.
- Show the people. If your strength is your team's experience, name the key personnel and their projects.
- Be honest. Overstating a role or a contract value can surface in reference checks and damage trust.
Next steps
- Build your one-page summary: how to write a capability statement.
- Find small, winnable opportunities in our search, filtered by set-aside, or scan your website for free to see which open notices match your company.
- See what evaluators look for in your field in our industry guides, such as management consulting and IT services.